In this A-Z Guide, we aim to inform you about the use of cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) in the treatment of drug and alcohol addiction. At Cassiobury Court, our alcohol rehab centre utilises CBT in the fight against addiction. CBT focuses on altering your thought patterns and resulting behaviours. In fact, CBT is used to treat a wide range of mental health problems including depression, anxiety disorders (social anxiety, panic disorder and post-traumatic stress), eating disorders as well as substance misuse.
What is CBT?
CBT seeks to break down psychological problems into smaller components, often trying to identify certain problematic thoughts and behaviours. Once these problematic thoughts have been broken down, CBT offers a straight forward way for your therapist to intervene and promote your recovery. You will also learn new techniques that make it less likely for you to face these identified psychological problems in the future.
A simple example
For example, say the environmental factor is you have a neighbour who waves to you every morning. One morning Peter sees his neighbour, Jane, but Jane doesn't wave at Peter. This causes Peter to think "I must have done something wrong." This thought causes Peter to experience light anxiety and discomfort. The next morning, Peter's behaviour is altered as Peter now tries to avoid Jane to avoid these bad feelings.
Later on, Peter's wife Carol also sees Jane. Jane also fails to wave at Carol. Unlike Peter, Carol assumes Jane must not have seen her. This thought doesn't affect Carol's mood so she does not attempt to avoid Jane the following day.
As you can see, the above illustrates thoughts and interpretation lead to two very different emotional and behavioural outcomes based on the same event (when Jane fails to wave at Peter and Carol).
The aim of CBT is to change the client's thought with the aim of ultimately altering the client's emotions and resulting behaviour.
The ABCDE model of CBT
The backbone of CBT is the ABCDE model. This model is summed up below:
- Activating Event – an event triggering automatic thoughts and resulting emotional consequences
- Belief – these are the automatic thoughts triggered by an event
- Consequence – this is how we feel about an event as interpreted through the lens of our beliefs
- Disputation – this is when we are encouraged to dispute the automatic thought
- Effective new belief – when the client is encouraged to produce more rational thoughts
The idea is that a negative activating event leads directly to unhappy consequences on the part of the person who experiences the event. CBT holds that it is not the activating event that leads to the unhappy consequences, but rather our beliefs and automatic thoughts surrounding the event. CBT holds that if we change our belief about the activating event, we can also change the emotional consequences of that event.
Utilising the ABCDE model, therapeutic clients are told to identify "activating events" that trigger automatic thoughts that lead to negative emotional consequences. Clients are then taught to dispute these thoughts by assessing the validity of these thoughts.
Whilst the client may find evidence in support of these thoughts, it's also likely he or she will discover evidence repudiating these thoughts. Clients are then encouraged to form effective new beliefs that do not encourage destructive behaviour and negative emotional consequences.
The three types of beliefs
CBT divides beliefs into three separate components:
- Inference/Automatic thoughts – these are thoughts that often unconsciously arise and so and not challenged
- Core belief/Schemas – these beliefs help shape the client's identify. These beliefs are shaped during childhood and reinforced during adulthood
- Evaluation – How we feel about ourselves as a result of inferences and core beliefs
CBT helps the client to identify, question and challenge automatic thoughts and core beliefs that cause psychological problems and destructive behaviours. During CBT sessions, clients discover the link between their thoughts, emotions and actions.
Challenging irrational inferences and automatic thoughts
Now we shall describe how the above three beliefs interact with each other. For instance, let's say you fail an exam. You may infer from this that you will always fail, so you will never amount to anything in life. This inference/automatic thought is accompanied with the core belief of "I have to successful in my career."
This inference and core belief lead to an evaluation that "I am a worthless individual." The consequence of this will be feelings of hopelessness, a lack of effort and general depression. The aim of CBT is to change these negative emotional consequences of hopelessness and depression by changing the client's core beliefs and automatic thoughts that arise when exposed to certain activating events.
The standard approach for CBT practitioners is to dispute the inference/automatic thoughts. The client is encouraged to challenge the belief that an exam failure means he or she will never amount to anything. Instead, the client is encouraged to interpret a negative event in a more positive manner, such as a need to work harder or prepare better in the future.
Although the client's core belief of "I have to be successful" is kept intact, his or her irrational inference to an activating event has altered so negative emotional consequence do not arise. Thus, even though the client has experienced the same activating event, he or she experiences a different emotional reaction because the inference has altered.
Challenging irrational core beliefs
Disputing the inference is not the only way to alter emotional responses and actions. CBT also attempts to help the client to affirm the inference by assuming the worst. For instance, if you fail your examination, you are encouraged to believe you will never 'amount to anything.'
CBT then attempts to dispute the core belief as opposed the inference. For example, you are taught to believe there is no reason to be successful in your career because this has no bearing on your worth as an individual.
You are taught to believe it may be inconvenient if you do not have a successful career, but this is not terrible by any stretch of the imagination. Your core belief in your need to be successful in your career has been substituted for a mere preference to be successful in your career.
Thus, although failing your exam makes you believe you will never amount to anything in life, this doesn't cause you to believe you are a worthless person because your core belief has been altered (since you no longer believe your absolutely must have a successful career.) You now believe you can go on and live a fulfilling and worthwhile life despite an unsuccessful career.
Let's meet Ted
Ted is a 58-year-old retail worker. Ted's manager, Peter, often gets very angry at Ted and shouts at him in front of his colleagues. Peter's anger is classed as the 'activating event.'
Let's analyse how this situation affects Ted's emotions and actions:
- Inferences: Ted infers that Peter doesn't believe he is doing his job correctly and conscientiously. He also infers that his co-workers believe he is incompetent.
- Core beliefs: Ted believes others must approve of him. He believes it's important that he should be appreciated by his colleagues and manager.
- Evaluation: Because Ted believes his manager and colleagues do not approve of him, they must be bad people and that it is awful he is being treated this way.
Challenging Ted's inferences/automatic thoughts
The consequence of the above is that Ted loses his temper and shouts back at Peter. Ted is also depressed and miserable at work as a result. The approach of CBT is to dispute the underlying inferences that arise when Peter shouts at Ted. For instance, Ted's therapist teaches him that because his boss shouts at him, it doesn't necessarily mean his boss is misjudging him or that his colleagues believe that he is incompetent.
Thanks to CBT, Ted now believes his manager shouts at him because his manager is struggling to cope with the demands of his own job, and not because Ted is incompetent. This is also the conclusion likely to have been drawn by Ted's colleagues. This means Ted now believes his colleagues do not conclude he is incompetent because of Peter's outbursts.
Although Ted's core belief that others must approve of him is intact, his inference/automatic thoughts have been altered to such a degree that negative emotional consequences no longer arise when Peter becomes angry with him.
Challenging Ted's core beliefs
Alternatively, Ted's therapist may assist him in disputing his underlying core belief that 'others must approve of him.' The therapist would also attempt to affirm the inference. Thus, Ted is told to assume the worse, that yes, his manager and colleagues believe he is incompetent.
However, Ted is also taught that other's approval is not something that will affect his sense of self-worth. Although Ted is aware that Peter and other colleagues many disprove of him, he now finds this easy to tolerate because he does not equate other's approval with his own sense of self-worth. Therefore, Ted doesn't become angry and act in a manner that is detrimental to his interests when he is exposed to this activating event.
Common beliefs often discovered in CBT sessions
The general philosophy of CBT is that the inferences and evaluations that give rise to people's psychological problems arise from core-beliefs. These core beliefs manifest as problems because a certain situation or state-of-being must be a certain way with no flexibility as to other outcomes.
CBT practitioners refer to this mentality as "musts," "shoulds" and "have-tos" i.e. you should behave in a certain way, you have to have a certain characteristic or you must be treated in a certain way by others.
Do you engage in MUST-urbation?
American psychologist Albert Ellis has termed this mentality as "MUST-urbation" and the "Tyranny of the shoulds."
Common neurotic automatic thoughts
Below we list a number of common neurotic automatic thoughts/cognitive distortions:
- Jumping to conclusions: I must be incompetent if I fail an exam
- Fortune telling: I will never amount to anything in life
- Over-generalisation: My colleagues think I am incompetent
- Black and white/polarised thinking: I cannot enjoy myself on holiday if the weather is bad
- Focusing on the negative: I am being treated with contempt at work
- Mind-reading: My boss is trying to intimidate me to work harder at work
- Magnification and filtering: Taking negative details from a situation and magnifying them whilst filtering out the positive
- Catastrophizing: Expecting disaster
CBT refers to the above as 'automatic negative thoughts' (NATs) or cognitive distortions. These NATs are challenged during CBT sessions using a range of cognitive restructuring exercises.
Common neurotic core-beliefs
- The need to succeed at all costs
- That others MUST treat you well
- The world MUST be a comfortable place
Common neurotic evaluations
The three most common evaluations arising from inflexible core beliefs are said to be:
- Awfulizing a situation as particular bad
- Low frustration tolerance i.e. that you cannot stand a situation to be a certain way
- People rating i.e. you should be rated as 'good' or 'bad':
Rationalising these distortions
CBT practitioners aim to rationalise these beliefs in a number of ways e.g:
- The need to succeed is replaced with unconditional self-acceptance i.e. one's sense of self-worth is independent to success in life
- The need for other's approval is replaced with unconditional other-acceptance i.e. one's sense of self-worth is independent to the approval of others
- The belief that the world must be a comfortable place is replaced with unconditional life-acceptance i.e. that things should be the way they actually are, and not the way you wish them to be
CBT as it applies to addiction treatment
Many people suffering from an addiction do so because they have established a number of negative thinking patterns and beliefs. Unfortunately, many of these people are not fully aware of these thought patterns and beliefs that fuel their destructive behaviours and poor emotional standing. CTB seeks to identify and then alter these negative thought patterns for the better. During CBT sessions, clients are taught to practice alternative thought patterns that reduce negative emotional consequences and their accompanying self-destructive behaviours.
How CBT assists sufferers of addiction
Specifically, CBT seeks to identify thought patterns directly linked to addictive behaviours. CBT also attempts to uncover core beliefs that support addictive behaviour. Once these thoughts and beliefs are altered, CBT seeks to help the client develop coping and avoidance strategies that make relapse less of a risk. This is achieved by helping the client alter thought patterns that directly cause or encourage destructive behaviours. This process is known as 'cognitive restructuring' or 'functional analysis'.
Thoughts that encourage addictive behaviours are known as 'trigger of addiction' or 'maladaptive cognitions.' Clients are asked to write about these thoughts as they arise in a Thought Record (TR). Over time, clients begin to realise how their thoughts and beliefs impact their behaviour and emotional well-being. This knowledge allows clients the ability to alter negative thoughts and beliefs so destructive behaviours are less likely to arise.
Making use of the ABCDE model for addiction treatment
Utilising the ABCDE model outlined before, clients are told to identify (1) activating events that trigger (2) automatic thoughts and beliefs that lead to negative (3) emotional consequences. Clients are then taught to (4) dispute these thoughts by assessing the validity of these thoughts. Whilst the client may find evidence in support of these thoughts, it's also likely they will discover evidence repudiating the validity of these thoughts. Clients are then encouraged to form (5) effective new beliefs that do not encourage destructive behaviour and negative emotional consequences.
How this works in practice
The therapist typically begins by getting the client to discuss his or her addiction by asking him or her a series of leading questions. The client may say something such as "I can't stop drinking alcohol." The therapist may ask "What does that mean about you?" The client reveals a core belief such as "Because I'm hopeless" or "I'm a total failure".
The therapist then helps the client collect evidence that either supports and discredits this belief. An attempt is then made to dispute this belief and then replace this belief with another more rational belief that doesn't result in addictive behaviours.
Common automatic thoughts discovered in addiction treatment
Below we list a number of common automatic thoughts often uncovered during CBT sessions for addiction treatment:
- “I’ve been addicted for years. I’ll never change.”
- “I’ve relapsed so many times; there’s obviously no hope for me.”
- "I can't relax without alcohol."
- "My friends would find me boring if I was sober."
- “I’m no good to anyone. I might as well keep using until I die.”
- “Why shouldn’t I drink/use drugs? My life is worthless anyway.”
Unfortunately, most clients are unaware that these beliefs and resulting thoughts are not completely accurate. This means clients hold these thoughts and beliefs for many years. CBT frees clients by allowing them to substitute these thoughts and beliefs for more rational and healthy alternatives.
Examples of healthier alternative beliefs
In time, these beliefs are substituted for the below healthier alternatives:
- “I deserve a healthy, positive life. I’m a worthwhile person.”
- "Lots of people have a good time without alcohol and I can be one of them."
- "My friends like me for my personality, not for my drinking."
- “I have the power and the skills to change my life if I want to.”
- “Relapse is a symptom of addiction, not a reflection of my personal strength.”
- “My life has purpose and meaning. I want to make it count.”
How CBT differs from traditional psychotherapy
Unlike traditional psychotherapy, CBT is a teaching and coaching approach to addiction treatment. Whilst traditional therapy looks at the long term reasons for why a client developed an addiction in the first place, CBT instead teaches clients how to not use drugs and alcohol right now and develop learning skills that help clients stay sober and avoid relapse.
Dealing with triggers of addiction
Triggers of addiction are physical and environmental 'activating events' that encourage continued drug/alcohol use and relapse. CBT says it's not these triggers themselves that result in relapse or encourage continued drug/alcohol use, but rather the client's underlying response to these triggers based on automatic thoughts and core beliefs.
Below we list a number of common 'triggers of addiction' our clients discuss during CBT sessions:
- Being around certain people
- Experiencing certain emotions
- Imagining experiences that occurred in the past
- Going to certain places
How CBT reduces the power of addiction triggers
CBT initially helps clients to identify these 'activating events'. Clients are subsequently assisted in identifying automatic thoughts and core beliefs that lead to negative emotional consequences and substance misuse when these activating events occur. Clients are then taught to challenge these automatic thoughts and emotions and substitute these thoughts and emotions with less destructive alternatives.
Additional coping strategies
Clients are also taught a number of additional 'coping strategies' to reduce the risk of relapse.
These strategies include:
- Listing the disadvantages of engaging in substance misuse
- Substituting substance misuse with 'sober activities'
- Learning about the "anhedonia" response that's common in the first 6 months of sobriety
- Learning holistic activities to reduce stress and manage cravings (e.g. mindfulness, yoga etc)
- The value of engaging in a support group
- Avoidance and refusal strategies
Following CBT sessions, clients are able to recognise situations and resulting thought patterns that promote drug and alcohol addiction, and then avoid or cope with these situations in less destructive ways.
- Rational Emotive Behaviour Therapy: A Reader by Windy Dryden
- Handbook of Rational-Emotive Therapy by Ellis & Grieger
- Cognitive-Behavioural Counselling in Action by Trowel, Casey & Dryden
- The Addiction Recovery Skills Workbook: Changing Addictive Behaviors Using CBT, Mindfulness, and Motivational Interviewing Techniques
- Adjustment and Personal Growth: Seven Pathways by Frank J. Bruno
- Cognitive-Behavioural Therapy in the Treatment of Addiction: A Treatment Planner for Clinicians by Kouimtsidis et al